The Joys of Dining Out in Summer

One of things I most look forward to when the warm weather finally shows up is eating outside.  I do like grilling and cooking outside, but if I go to a restaurant and have a choice of eating inside or … Continue reading

Restaurant and Brewery Review: Erie Brewing Company

A few years ago, when the Lake Erie Ale Trail was initially advertised, I traveled and visited the breweries (and wrote about it here).  All of the breweries but one–Erie Brewing Company— because it was only open on the weekends.  … Continue reading

New Restaurant Brings Innovative Dining to Marina

I have been waiting (excitedly) for the new waterfront restaurant in North East to open.  I have always loved the dining space there, and have found it the perfect spot to enjoy a cocktail and one of our gorgeous Great … Continue reading

Lake Erie Winery Update/Take 3

Our travels this time took us to New York; we visited Mazza Chautauqua Cellars/Five and 20 Spirits and Woodbury Winery and Vineyards.  The trip to Mazza coincides with our effort to visit wineries that have food available for visitors. Mazza … Continue reading

Lake Erie Winery Update/Take 2

We are off again on our quest to re-visit all of the wineries!  This time we chose two other local North East wineries, Presque Isle and Courtyard.  We get many requests from guests about wineries that serve good–so we wanted … Continue reading

Reboot: Pie in the Sky Restaurant Review


Exterior of Pie in the Sky Restaurant

Exterior of Pie in the Sky Restaurant

Don’t let the exterior fool you!   We went back to eat at Erie Restaurant Pie in the Sky after an absence of several years.   It was one of Grape Arbor Bed and Breakfast’s favorite spaces when we first arrived in town, but we have been lured to other, more recent additions to the restaurant scene.


It is hidden away on 8th street, with on street parking only.  Originally a breakfast and lunch spot, it is now only weekend dining.

Interior Pie in the Sky

Interior Pie in the Sky

The interior has a funky, artsy modern bistro feel.  As a warning–there is no liquor license, but they are more than happy to open and serve any bottle of wine that you might bring.

We ordered the appetizer special, which was a Bruschetta with artichokes, an olive spread and covered with cheese. I am not usually a fan of olives, but this added just the right salty bite.

The standard menu was familiar, and I remembered the lamb shanks from previous visits and ordered.  It arrived fit for Henry VIII–huge and fragrant with garlic, mashed potatoes and crunchy veggies.  The meat was super tender and flavorful, I couldn’t finish even half of it.

My companion ordered one of the night’s specials, which was a Mako shark cooked Piccata style–with capers and lemon butter sauce.  There was some discussion of the degree of done-ness of the fish, the waiter was quite accommodating.  When it arrived, it was quite a large gorgeous piece of fish, cooked perfectly, except for the thickest part (which was a bit undercooked for her taste).  Asparagus and potatoes rounded out the plate.

lamb shank

Lamb Shank

We ordered a salad, which was unremarkable, and had to ask for rolls (which we saw on other diner’s tables) which were also standard.


I was looking forward to dessert, which I had remembered as being my favorite part of the meal.  We were told they were all made in house.  My memory was of a wonderful rice pudding, which, unfortunately, was missing from the menu.  We settled on Creme Brulee and a Chocolate Mousse Cake.   We were disappointed with both.  The crispy sugar coating on the creme brulee was too generous, making it difficult to break into piece and eat.  The chocolate cake was super rich, and had a berry puree garnish.


mako shark

Mako Shark

Overall, we enjoyed our visit–the two items we ordered are not normally found on other restaurant menus in the city.  It was not a noisy place, and we could talk comfortably.


The Details:

Pie in the Sky

463 W. 8th St

Erie PA   16502

Phone:    (814) 459-8638




Harbor House in Harborcreek Scores Big on Variety

There is a new addition to the restaurant scene close to the Grape Arbor!  We have long enjoyed the food and atmosphere of the Tap House in downtown Erie, and now there is a sister restaurant, just a few minutes … Continue reading